Metal vs. Asphalt: A Deep Dive into Roofing Choices

by | Jun 18, 2024 | Blog | 0 comments

Selecting the ideal roofing material is a pivotal decision for every homeowner. The debate often centers around two primary contenders: the enduring metal roofs and the popular asphalt shingles. Both have their distinct merits and potential drawbacks. At Super Roofers, we’ve delved deep to present an unbiased comparison to aid your decision-making process.

1. Evaluating Material Expenses: Upfront and Over Time

Asphalt Shingles: Widely favored for their cost-effectiveness, asphalt shingles typically come in at around $160 for every 100 square feet. Depending on the brand and quality, the total material expenditure for an asphalt roof can oscillate between $5,000 and $10,000.

Metal Roofs: These are a premium choice, with initial costs often being two to three-fold higher than their asphalt counterparts. However, their extended lifespan, minimal repair frequency, superior energy conservation, and potential to elevate property value make them a long-term investment to consider.

2. Installation: Labor and Associated Charges

The region, roof intricacies, and material choice can influence installation charges.

Asphalt Shingles: Typically, homeowners might spend between $200–$300 per square foot for installation. For a roof spanning 1,500 square feet, this translates to labor charges in the ballpark of $3,000–$4,500.

Metal Roofs: Given their specialized installation requirements, metal roofs can command between $300–$500 per square foot in labor costs. For a roof of similar size, this could mean an outlay of $4,500–$7,500.

3. Roof Design: Complexity and Cost Implications

A roof’s design intricacies can significantly sway the final bill. Features like multiple valleys, intricate pitches, or unique design elements can amplify costs. Key cost influencers include:

  • Ease of roof access
  • Proximity of plumbing and gas fixtures
  • Roof elevation
  • Valley configurations

4. Pre-Installation: Addressing Pre-existing Concerns

Prior to embarking on a new installation, it’s imperative to rectify any pre-existing damages. Issues like moisture infiltration or compromised structural elements can impede the new installation. The costs for these repairs can vary but ensuring a robust base for your new roof is non-negotiable.

5. Warranty Insights and Roof Longevity

Asphalt Shingles: Manufacturers typically offer robust warranties initially, which may transition to prorated or limited ones as years progress. Asphalt shingles generally promise a lifespan ranging from 10 to 30 years.

Metal Roofs: Some premium metal roofs come with lifetime warranties. Depending on the chosen metal, these roofs can serve homeowners for durations spanning 30 years to an impressive century, especially with metals like steel or copper.

6. Upkeep and Repair Dynamics

Consistent maintenance can prolong the life of any roofing material. Metal roofs, while potentially pricier to mend due to material and labor costs, tend to demand less routine upkeep than asphalt variants.

Super Roofers: Your Trusted Partner

Super Roofers stands as a beacon of excellence in Daphne, Al. Whether you’re leaning towards a sleek metal finish or the classic asphalt shingles, our seasoned roofer team in Daphne, Al, is equipped to assist. With a rich legacy in roofing services in Daphne, Al, we guarantee impeccable craftsmanship and enduring results.

In Conclusion

The choice between metal and asphalt shingles hinges on your financial allocation, aesthetic leanings, and long-term aspirations for your residence. Both materials bring unique advantages to the table. It’s always prudent to engage with reputable roofing contractors in Daphne, Al, to ensure a seamless and proficient installation experience.